Why CoinPulse rated OpenSea 9.16 in NFT marketplaces
NFT marketplaces are scored on four criteria: Track record (34%), Latency (24%), Status transparency (22%) and Security record (20%). There is no on-chain value to weigh for a marketplace, so the profile leans on how long a service has operated and how it behaves from outside. Scale of value trusted, Security audits, Multi-chain reach and Peg stability are not scored in this category.
OpenSea's total is Track record 10 × 34% = 3.4, plus Status transparency 10 × 22% = 2.2, plus Latency 9 × 24% = 2.16, plus Security record 7 × 20% = 1.4, which comes to 9.16. All four criteria were measured, so coverage is 100% and no weight was redistributed. Of the 0.84 points missing, 0.6 come from the Security record and 0.24 from Latency. The rules behind each criterion are on the methodology page.
Where OpenSea scored well
Track record: 3,398 days, the longest in the category
The rating counts 3,398 days of operation since OpenSea's 2017 launch, from the public record, against a category median of 1,937 days. A launch known only by its year is counted from July 1 of that year. That earns the full 10 on the heaviest-weighted criterion. Most services that fail do so early, so time survived is treated as signal. It shows continuity of operation, not the safety of any particular listing or wallet connection.
Status transparency: a feed anyone can audit
OpenSea publishes a Statuspage feed at status.opensea.io that the rating could parse, which scores 10. The category median is 2, because most NFT marketplaces have no public status page at all. Magic Eden and MagicEden Runes also score 10 here.
Over the 90 days the incident history covered, the feed showed 0 incidents logged and 0 that OpenSea itself labelled major or critical. That is measured-not-scored context: it reflects how OpenSea labels its own incidents, and an empty feed is not an uptime guarantee.
Latency: 216 ms, one band below the top
Our probe timed the opensea.io interface at a median of 216 ms to first byte, two of three samples with the slowest discarded, from a single location. That scored 9, just under the category median score of 9.5, and is slower than the category's 185 ms median. It measures how fast the website answered one probe, not how quickly trades settle on-chain or how the site performs elsewhere.
Where OpenSea lost points
Security record: two 2022 incidents in DefiLlama's database
DefiLlama's hack database, checked on October 19, 2026, records two incidents matched to OpenSea by name. The first, dated January 25, 2022, is classed as a withdrawal logic flaw with a reported amount of $1.0 million. The second, dated February 20, 2022, is classed as phishing with a reported amount of $2.0 million. DefiLlama records no returned amount for either.
Under the method, a loss between $1 million and $10 million marks 5, and incidents older than three years count two points less, so each incident marks 7 and the worst one sets the score at 7. The category median is 10, since most marketplaces have no match in the database. The score reflects reported amounts as DefiLlama lists them; it does not establish how much any individual user lost or what OpenSea changed afterwards.
What the OpenSea score does not tell you about safety
The rating reads operational signals from public data: age, site response time, status-page transparency and DefiLlama's hack record. It does not test smart contracts, review listing moderation, check for counterfeit collections or assess exposure to phishing links and malicious signature requests. Those are the questions behind "is OpenSea safe", and the score cannot answer them on its own.
Fees, royalties, liquidity, usability and support are not scored for any marketplace. Security incidents that never became a DefiLlama entry are not scored either. The score is not a certification of safety, legality or solvency. How the site is financed is set out on how this is funded.
How OpenSea compares in the NFT marketplaces ranking
Magic Eden leads at 10 with full marks on all four criteria. Against it, OpenSea gives up 0.24 points on Latency (9 against 10) and 0.6 on Security record (7 against 10). MagicEden Runes is second at 9.32: it is younger and scores 8 on Track record, a 0.68-point disadvantage, but its 10 on Latency and Security record outweighs that by 0.84, leaving it 0.16 ahead.
Below OpenSea, Manifold scores 8.24. It beats OpenSea on Latency and Security record but has no public status page, which costs it 1.76 points on Status transparency. Zora follows at 8.18 for the same kind of reason: a blocked status page and a slower site. OpenSea's third place rests on its status feed; its hack record is what keeps it out of the top two.
What the OpenSea rating means for you
On the measured evidence, OpenSea is one of the most transparent and longest-running NFT marketplaces in the ranking, with a public incident feed that anyone can check. Its two 2022 entries in DefiLlama's database are the reason it does not score higher. Before using it, check the contract you are signing for, verify collection links yourself and read the current status page; the rating does not do that for you.