Gemini vs Bitstamp: crypto exchange scores compared
Gemini scores 9.56/10 and Bitstamp 9.18/10 on CoinPulse's crypto exchange ranking (#2 and #3 of 19), on data collected October 19, 2026. Both have 100% of the score measured. Almost the whole gap is one old incident: Bitstamp has a January 2015 phishing loss of $5.2M in DefiLlama's hack database, and Gemini has none. Bitstamp claws back a little on latency. Reserves, track record and status transparency are level.
Data collected October 19, 2026 · No affiliate links
Gemini scores higher: 9.56/10 against 9.18/10. It leads on 1 of 5 criteria, Bitstamp on 1.
Criterion by criterion
Same category, same weights, heaviest criterion first. Open a row for each side’s reasoning and evidence.
Scale of value trusted28% of the scoreLevelGemini9Bitstamp9Why these marks ↓Hide ↑
Track record20% of the scoreLevelGemini10Bitstamp10Why these marks ↓Hide ↑
Status transparency18% of the scoreLevelGemini10Bitstamp10Why these marks ↓Hide ↑
Security record18% of the scoreGemini leadsGemini10Bitstamp7Why these marks ↓Hide ↑
Latency16% of the scoreBitstamp leadsGemini9Bitstamp10Why these marks ↓Hide ↑
What explains the 0.38-point gap
- Security record (+0.54 to Gemini). A $5.2M loss falls in the under-$10M band (5). Because it is more than three years old it gains two points, so Bitstamp scores 7. Gemini, with nothing recorded among 1,307 incidents, scores 10. Three marks at 18% weight is 0.54 points.
- Latency (+0.16 to Bitstamp). 60 ms earns 10 and 114 ms earns 9.
- Net: 0.54 − 0.16 = 0.38.
In practice, the ranking difference reflects an incident from more than a decade ago. The method already softens it by two points for age; readers who discount old incidents further will see these two as close.
What is level
- Reserves. Both score 9. Gemini's $5.43B is larger than Bitstamp's $4.67B, but on the log scale both sit in the same band.
- Track record. Bitstamp has operated three years longer (15.3 vs 12.3), but both are well past the full-mark threshold.
- Status transparency. Both publish full machine-readable incident archives. For context only: over the 90-day window, Gemini's feed logged 7.33 incidents per 30 days (median 203 minutes to resolution) and Bitstamp's 2 per 30 days (median 312 minutes). Companies log at different granularity, so this is not scored.
One structural note: Bitstamp has been owned by Robinhood since the acquisition closed in June 2025 (The Block). The method scores Bitstamp on its own record; a product line never inherits a parent company's incidents. See Robinhood vs Bitstamp.
What is not measured
Fees and spreads, supported coins and fiat rails, products such as cards or staking, app experience, support quality, licences and whether either exchange serves your state or country are outside the score. Check each company's own fee schedule and terms. Company background: Gemini profile · Bitstamp profile.
Which fits which reader
- Clean hack history matters most to you: Gemini — nothing in DefiLlama's database; Bitstamp has one 2015 phishing loss.
- You value the longest operating history: Bitstamp, 15.3 years (tied with two others as the longest in the category).
- You are latency-sensitive (API traders): Bitstamp, 60 ms vs 114 ms in our single-location probe — verify from your own location.
- You want to audit outages: either; both publish full archives.
The numbers side by side
| Measured | Gemini | Bitstamp |
|---|---|---|
| Value locked | $5.43B | $4.67B |
| Track record | 12.3 yr | 15.3 yr |
| Latency (our probe) | 114 ms | 60 ms |
| Hacks on record | 0 | 1 |
| Status feed | statuspage | statuspage |
Where each one falls short
Bitstamp
Security record: 1 hack on record in DefiLlama’s database: 2015-01 phishing ($5.2M). Scored on what users lost after any funds were returned, with older incidents weighing less.
Which to choose
Which is better, Bitstamp or Gemini?+
On October 19, 2026 data Gemini scores higher, 9.56 to 9.18. The difference is mostly Bitstamp's 2015 $5.2M phishing loss; fees, app quality and availability are not part of either score.
Is Bitstamp safe compared with Gemini?+
The scores show public evidence, not safety. Both have large tracked reserves, long histories and public status archives. Bitstamp has one hack on record (2015); Gemini has none. Both are custodial.
Is this the same comparison as Robinhood vs Bitstamp?+
No. Robinhood owns Bitstamp, but each is rated separately on its own data. Compare more: all 19 crypto exchanges · Robinhood vs Gemini · Bitstamp vs Bitvavo