Ledger vs Trezor: what the open data shows
Ledger scores 9.82/10 and Trezor 8.9/10 on CoinPulse's hardware wallet ranking (#1 and #2 of 15), on data collected October 19, 2026. Both have 100% of the score measured. Almost all of Ledger's lead comes from one criterion: it publishes a machine-readable incident archive, while Trezor's status page could not be read by our script. Trezor has the cleaner hack record. Neither score tests the devices' security design — the question most Ledger-vs-Trezor buyers are really asking — so read this as maker-level evidence, not a verdict on which device protects keys better.
Data collected October 19, 2026 · No affiliate links
Ledger scores higher: 9.82/10 against 8.9/10. It leads on 1 of 4 criteria, Trezor on 1.
Criterion by criterion
Same category, same weights, heaviest criterion first. Open a row for each side’s reasoning and evidence.
Track record40% of the scoreLevelLedger10Trezor10Why these marks ↓Hide ↑
Status transparency22% of the scoreLedger leadsLedger10Trezor5Why these marks ↓Hide ↑
Latency20% of the scoreLevelLedger10Trezor10Why these marks ↓Hide ↑
Security record18% of the scoreTrezor leadsLedger9Trezor10Why these marks ↓Hide ↑
What explains the 0.92-point gap
- Status transparency (+1.10 to Ledger). Ledger's status page publishes a full incident archive anyone can check. Trezor has a status page, but it offers no feed in the formats the probe reads (statuspage, incident.io, instatus), so it scores 5 — "readable, not auditable". The card notes this may partly be a blind spot of the method rather than a Trezor shortcoming.
- Security record (+0.18 to Trezor). Ledger's DefiLlama entry is a November 2020 phishing incident with $271,000 lost (under $1M = 7, plus 2 for age = 9). Trezor has none.
- Net: 1.10 − 0.18 = 0.92.
Track record and latency are level: both makers have shipped devices for more than 12 years, and both websites responded in under 120 ms.
For context, not scoring: Ledger's status page showed "Degraded" at collection and logged 18.75 incidents per 30 days over the 80 days its feed covers, with a median 26 minutes to resolution. A busy archive is a sign of transparency, not necessarily of worse reliability; Trezor's equivalent figures cannot be read.
What the scores say about security — and what they don't
The security record criterion counts hacks in DefiLlama's public database matched to each maker's own entry. It says Trezor has no recorded incident and Ledger has one 2020 phishing case. It does not cover:
- Device design. Secure elements, open-source versus closed firmware, seed-backup features, passphrase support and physical attack resistance are not measured — and these are where Ledger and Trezor differ most.
- Related software incidents. The December 2023 supply-chain attack on Ledger's Connect Kit library, which Ledger estimated cost users about $600,000, is not part of Ledger's record under the exact-name rule (BleepingComputer).
- Data leaks without a recorded loss, and attacks on individual users.
Use independent security research and each maker's documentation for those questions.
What is not measured
Price, model range, supported coins, companion-app usability, customer support and shipping regions are outside the score. The score is per maker, not per model, so it does not compare a specific Ledger Nano or Stax with a specific Trezor Safe device. Company background: Ledger profile · Trezor profile.
Which fits which reader
- You want a maker whose outage history you can audit: Ledger — the only hardware wallet in the ranking with a full machine-readable archive.
- You want no hack on record: Trezor.
- You value the longest operating history: Trezor, 13.3 years — the longest of the 15 makers ranked.
- Your decision turns on device security or usability: these scores do not settle it.
Also weighing Coldcard or Tangem? Coldcard scores 6.2 (a $116.0M key-generation incident in July 2026) and Tangem 7.64 in the full hardware wallet ranking.
The numbers side by side
| Measured | Ledger | Trezor |
|---|---|---|
| Track record | 12.3 yr | 13.3 yr |
| Latency (our probe) | 81 ms | 114 ms |
| Hacks on record | 1 | 0 |
| Status feed | statuspage | unknown |
Where each one falls short
Trezor
Status transparency: A status page exists but publishes no feed we could parse — readable, not auditable. Part of that may be our blind spot (we read three platforms).
Which to choose
Trezor vs Ledger: which scores higher?+
Ledger, 9.82 to 8.9, on October 19, 2026 data. The lead comes from status-page transparency; Trezor leads on hack record.
Is Trezor safer than Ledger?+
The data cannot answer that. It shows Trezor has no hack recorded in DefiLlama's database and Ledger has one 2020 phishing incident. Device security design is not measured.
Does this compare specific models like Trezor Safe 3 and Ledger Nano?+
No. Scores are for each maker and its companion service, not individual devices. Compare more: Ledger vs Blockstream Jade · Trezor vs Blockstream Jade