All 15 tokens held their peg on October 19, so peg stability gave every one of them 10/10. The ranking is decided by the other three criteria.
Scale is the biggest lever
Market cap carries 38% of the score and is read on a log scale. Only Tether and USD Coin score 10; every other coin, from $1.23B to $7.02B, scores 9. That single point costs 0.38, which is the whole gap between Dai and the top two. It also means Sky Dollar's $7.02B and BlackRock USD's $2.17B count the same here.
Track record splits the 2023–2026 launches
Age is the criterion that spreads the middle of the table. Coins launched in 2014–2018 score 10; 3.2–3.3 years scores 9; 2.3–2.7 years scores 8; 1.3–1.8 years scores 6; USDGO's 111 days scores 2. At 24% weight, each point is 0.24. That is why Sky Dollar, the third-largest coin in the table at $7.02B, sits at 9 rather than higher.
Reach is a tie-breaker
Chains carry 14%. On this collection, 15 or more chains earned 10, 6–8 chains earned 9, 2–4 chains earned 8, and USDGO's single chain earned 6. Reach alone moves a score by 0.14–0.56.
Yield-bearing tokens are scored differently
Ondo US Dollar Yield and Circle USYC pass interest to holders through the token's price, so they traded at $1.1505 and $1.1408. The method scores them on not falling below $1 rather than on distance from $1. They are listed beside payment stablecoins because they occupy a similar on-chain role, but they are different products with different holder eligibility; see the Ondo and Circle profiles.